D1 Training has successfully defended itself against legal claims made by a former franchise owner after an independent arbitrator ruled entirely in the company’s favor.
The dispute was brought by Alex Nicholas, who formerly owned a D1 Training facility in Naples, Florida. He accused the franchisor of fraud and misrepresentation, but the arbitrator determined that the evidence did not establish those claims.
Nicholas originally filed the case against D1 Sports Franchise in April 2025. The filing took place in Williamson County, Tennessee, the home of D1 Training’s corporate headquarters.
The parties participated in a four-day arbitration hearing in February. On May 18, arbitrator John T. Blankenship denied all claims against the company, formally ending the dispute.
The Company Returns Its Attention to Athletes and Owners
Legal disagreements can be challenging for any franchise organization, especially when they involve a former operator. With the case complete, D1 Training is looking ahead and emphasizing the work taking place throughout its franchise community.
CEO Will Bartholomew said the company remains committed to its franchise owners and the athletes who train at its facilities. Its priorities include helping local operators build healthy businesses and ensuring customers receive dependable, professional coaching.
D1 Training supports its owners through marketing assistance, operational advice, business coaching and education. These services are intended to give franchisees a framework for managing their locations without losing the local connection that is important in the fitness industry.
Measuring Real Athletic Progress
A major part of D1 Training’s strategy involves showing athletes how they are improving rather than relying only on how a workout feels.
The company’s D1 Verified program is designed for athletes from 14 to 18 years old. Coaches use a structured testing process to measure performance and document development over time. This can help athletes understand where they are progressing and which areas still need attention.
The Athlete Performance Index offers another way to evaluate ability. Athletes complete standardized tests similar to those used at competitive sports combines. Their results are then placed on a five-star scale and compared with established college recruiting benchmarks.
D1 Training is also placing greater emphasis on coach education. Enhanced certification standards are meant to give coaches a consistent approach while helping athletes advance safely and effectively.
For franchise owners, these programs provide structured services that can set their facilities apart in a crowded fitness market. For athletes and parents, they offer clearer information about training outcomes.
From College Football to a National Fitness Brand
D1 Training’s concept is based on the environment of a Division I college training facility. Its coach-led sessions combine strength, conditioning and athletic development, with programs adapted for different ages and experience levels.
The company was founded in 2002 by Will Bartholomew, whose background is closely connected to high-level sports. He played football at the University of Tennessee, contributed to the team’s 1998 national championship and served as captain in 2001.
Bartholomew later signed with the Denver Broncos, but an injury ended his playing career before the season started. He eventually channelled his experience into building D1 Training and making collegiate-style coaching available outside a university setting.
Since then, the company has gained national attention in the fitness and franchise sectors. The arbitration decision closes one difficult chapter, allowing D1 Training to continue concentrating on its owners, coaches and athletes.
Learn more about D1 Training franchise opportunities.
